Fillers for Reduced Rifle Loads

Fillers for Reduced Rifle Loads
Reasons to be concerned about using fillers for reduced loads include they are very inconsistent, they are not stable, and they usually produce a lot of residue.
After I published a column on reduced rifle reloads, several readers asked about fillers and why their use has fallen off. Fillers are non-energetic solids placed in a cartridge to reduce airspace, maintain the propellant’s position, or both. They generally fall into two classes: fiber “puffballs” and granular. I want to talk about the puffballs—to me they are the most troublesome.

Puffball fillers are wads of lightweight fiber and can be natural, like kapok, or synthetic, like polyester fiberfill. Think “pillow stuffing.” Years ago, published reloading information suggested puffball fillers for reduced loads where better ballistic uniformity was needed. You pushed a puffball of the fiber on top of the propellant charge. However, the recommendations rather quickly slowed and, in some cases, stopped.

I knew Dave Andrews, my predecessor at Speer, long before I was hired to fill his shoes. At a trade show in the early 1980s, I asked him why the puffball fad had faded so dramatically. “Ringed chambers” was his short answer.

Andrews said the rings were in the range of a quarter-inch to a half-inch wide and usually found mid-chamber. No catastrophic failures of firearms or cartridge cases heralded the appearance of the rings. Andrews said most were discovered when a cartridge case that otherwise appeared undamaged was hard to extract.

My quandary is this: I participated in a forensic exam of the sad remains of a custom .257 Weatherby Magnum bolt-action rifle built on a high-quality commercial M98 Mauser action. The owner had, we eventually concluded, destroyed the rifle by confusing a full case of IMR 4064 for the slower IMR 4350, creating pressures we estimated to be over 80,000 psi. (For those who don’t know, the SAAMI maximum average pressure for the .257 Weatherby is 65,000 psi.) Despite the rest of the rifle being “morselized,” the Harry McGowen custom barrel was totally undamaged. It and the buttplate were the only parts of the rifle that survived in reusable condition.

Careful examination showed the chamber was still comfortably within specifications and was not ringed. Thus, a rifle-shredding load did no damage to a chamber, but reports said puffball loads were creating rings in chambers with very modest propellant charges. This happened without causing the cartridge case to fail or even show other than normal stress. The single common denominator was that ringing was limited to chambers that had fired puffball filler loads. This didn’t add up. How do you put a ring in high-strength steel without first losing integrity of a much weaker brass case?

Although symptoms suggest exotic collisions of pressure wave fronts, I don’t have a definitive answer to this one. I always felt like a biologist during my career as a ballistician, capturing something for study in the lab. If I could assess the problem in a transducer barrel configured for time-pressure output, I could learn a lot. Unfortunately, the chamber-ringing mystery required experiments I could not afford. In 2002 I was paying $700 to $1,200 for one SAAMI-compliant pressure barrel. A couple of ringed chambers would mean less money for loading manual development. If ringing took out the conformal transducer too, that was another $700 in the “Oops” column.

So we have a little problem that is not unlike the Loch Ness Monster. Suggestions of Nessie’s existence continue to surface, but we’ve never managed to get one into the laboratory for a good look-see and a poke or two.

The Ballistician’s Concerns

I’m reticent to guess about something I can’t test. Rather, I prefer to present issues I see with puffball filler loads that don’t have to ring a chamber to trigger my ballistician’s red flag. The first is consistency and repeatability. It is quite hard to get the same amount of “puff” in every case and just as hard to come up with a consistent tamp method. As handloaders, most of us embrace the idea of doing everything to make each cartridge as much like its lot mates as possible. To me, the inconsistencies of puffball filler assembly are a step in the wrong direction.

My second concern is stability. Puffball proponents never advised filling the case, rather using the fiber to wedge the propellant charge against the case bottom leaving airspace above. Even were the case filled with a puffball, it would not be stable. Smokeless propellants are much denser than compressed fiberfill material. Any bump can cause the dense propellant to unseat the ultra-light puffball. Once the filler shifts, the propellant can mix with it, reducing the effectiveness of the charge. That could cause a bullet in the bore. Even driving the puffball cartridges to the range in your vehicle can reduce any semblance of uniformity to rubbish before the first round is fired. Likewise, the recoil of one round in a repeating rifle will dislodge the puffball in all the remaining cartridges in the magazine.

Another issue is residue. I’ve examined cases fired with polyester fillers that showed heavy black deposits inside where the shoulder meets the neck. Yes, a heavier propellant charge might have been able to combust more of the residue before it deposited, but it still concerns me. I don’t want that stuff going down my rifle barrels.

Granular fillers work very differently but are still no cure-all. The best is a natural one: farina, a semolina wheat product used for hot “creamed wheat” cereals. Relatively fine grains and a rough texture help the granules grip each other under pressure, making it easier to compress. Still, it is not an easy chore to consistently load and compress farina to give full confidence that filler and fuel won’t mix. It also needs to fill the case after compression, adding mass that requires charge weight adjustments. It’s not worth the trouble; I use farina for where it shines: case-forming blanks. Any time you need to neck up a cartridge, say the .30-06 to .338-06, the filler-charged case-forming blank will do it with consistency and a fraction of the defects an expander ball can induce.

I am content with foregoing fillers and enjoying the excellent selection of today’s propellants that are engineered for reduced charges, such as Accurate 5744 and Hodgdon Trail Boss.

Recommended for You

Considering how popular the .270 Winchester has become, it's a great mystery why more .270 caliber (6.8mm) rifle cartridges  have not been introduced. Ammo

5 Great .270 Rifle Cartridges

Layne Simpson - May 28, 2019

Considering how popular the .270 Winchester has become, it's a great mystery why more .270...

A half-century in the making, the new DGX Bonded is Hornady's best-ever dangerous-game bullet. Ammo

Danger Tamed: Hornady DGX Bonded Hunting Ammo

Joseph von Benedikt - May 23, 2019

A half-century in the making, the new DGX Bonded is Hornady's best-ever dangerous-game bullet.

Daniel Defense has blazed a new trail with its first-ever bolt-action rifle, the Daniel Defense Delta 5. Rifles

Daniel Defense Delta 5 Review

Joel J. Hutchcroft - May 31, 2019

Daniel Defense has blazed a new trail with its first-ever bolt-action rifle, the Daniel...

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Hornady 6MM Creedmoor

Hornady 6MM Creedmoor

Tom Beckstrand and Neal Emery of Hornady highlight the 6MM Creedmoor ammo.

Springfield Armory Saint Victor

Springfield Armory Saint Victor

The SAINT' Victor Rifle delivers a lightweight and agile rifle solution while maintaining effectiveness at extended engagement distances.

Pinging Steel At Over A Mile Away

Pinging Steel At Over A Mile Away

Big bore semiauto or a lever gun? We look at the futuristic .450 Bushmaster and how it compares to the tried and true .45-70. ISS Prop House gives us the rundown on the guns used in Enemy at the Gate. We ping steel with a .300 WinMag at over a mile.

See more Popular Videos

Trending Stories

These cheap postwar variants offer perhaps the best value on the vintage-Mauser market. Rifles

Yugoslavian M24/47 Mauser-Pattern Rifle

Joseph von Benedikt - May 13, 2019

These cheap postwar variants offer perhaps the best value on the vintage-Mauser market.

Burris has expanded its top-of-the-line Veracity hunting riflescope line with new 2-10X 42mm and 3-15X 50mm RFP (rear focal plane) models. Optics

Burris Veracity RFP Riflescopes

Jake Edmondson - June 04, 2019

Burris has expanded its top-of-the-line Veracity hunting riflescope line with new 2-10X 42mm...

Crimson Trace enters the riflescope business with the Crimson Trace CTL-3420 4-20X 50mm. Optics

Review: Crimson Trace CTL-3420 4-20X 50mm

Joel J. Hutchcroft - April 29, 2019

Crimson Trace enters the riflescope business with the Crimson Trace CTL-3420 4-20X 50mm.

See More Stories

More Reloading

The .224 Valkyrie was created to provide optimal long-range performance, and matching factory-load ballistics with handloads is relatively easy. Reloading

.224 Valkyrie Reloading Tips

Lane Pearce - January 29, 2019

The .224 Valkyrie was created to provide optimal long-range performance, and matching...

Where too little pressure can cause as much trouble as too much pressure, the short .44 Russian and .45 Schofield cases offer a compelling benefit. Reloading

.44 Russian, .45 Schofield Case Capacity

Allan Jones - September 09, 2019

Where too little pressure can cause as much trouble as too much pressure, the short .44...

Successfully handloading for a 308 AR hinges on determining just the right amount of a compatible propellant. Reloading

308 Load Data for ARs

Lane Pearce - September 30, 2019

Successfully handloading for a 308 AR hinges on determining just the right amount of a...

See More Reloading

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Temporary Price Reduction

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.