Skip to main content

Readers Declare Their 'One-Gun ' Choices

Readers Declare Their 'One-Gun ' Choices

After chiming in with his choice, the reader's respond to the Sheriff

Recently I got my two cents worth in on the old debate concerning which gun I would have if I could only have one gun. You might recall that I decided my one gun would be a handgun, and after studying the uses I have for a handgun, I settled on a medium-frame .357 Magnum double-action revolver. Over the years I have spent quite a lot of time with the Smith & Wesson Model 19 and Model 66, now discontinued, but I could live quite happily with the new seven-shot L-Frame Models 619 and 620.

Several readers chose big-bore revolvers, such as Smith & Wesson's Mountain Gun, as their choice if they were limited to having only one gun.

At the end of that column I invited readers to share their one-gun choices with me. I thought you might be interested in some of the responses I received.


My comments were focused on handguns, but I mentioned that many others might choose rifles or shotguns. Adam Hollinghead was one of those. Adam's one-gun choice is the Winchester Model 94 in the dependable .30-30 chambering. Adam points out that the carbine is short, light, and easy to handle. He builds light handloads for plinking and small-game hunting and uses factory ammo when full power is needed. He correctly points out that any store that stocks any ammunition at all will generally have some .30-30 cartridges on the shelf.


Another interesting response was offered from Jack Scofield, whose favorite handgun is a Browning Hi-Power. Back in 1970 Jack was a gunner on a Huey in Vietnam and packed a Hi-Power in a shoulder rig. During one fiery episode, Jack was working his M60 when an enemy rifle round slammed into the left side of his chest. The round had hit his Hi-Power, destroying it, but the Hi-Power prevented the bullet from penetrating his chest. Jack recently sent a Hi-Power off for some custom work like I'd had done on my own Browning, and he was really pleased with the outcome. My bet is that Jack will be packing this custom Hi-Power for some time to come.

Pat Cascio and Joe Johnson both wrote to agree with my choice of a .357 Magnum revolver. Pat is a handgun instructor and writer who hails from the Northwest, and if I recall correctly, his preferred .357 Magnum is the old K-Frame Smith & Wesson. Joe, on the other hand, prefers the Model 686 Mountain Gun from Smith & Wesson. It is an L-Frame revolver similar to the current Model 620, and Joe has had his modified to accept full-moon clips.


And I certainly can't argue with Bill Sullivan and Dave Tippets, who both choose a .44 Magnum. Bill didn't specify which .44 he packs but indicated that he owned several. Dave, on the other hand, gives the nod to the 4-inch Model 29 or 629. Both men correctly point out that the .44 Magnum has an extremely flexible power level. The handloader can work up whatever power loads he needs, from .44 Special to full-house .44 Magnum. Factory ammunition offers the same broad spectrum of choice. Folks who live in bear country are wise to consider the big .44.


Other big-bore choices were expressed by Ray Tuftee and Will DeRuyter. Ray chooses the Smith & Wesson Mountain Gun in .41 Magnum and says that he enjoys shooting it much more than his other .44- and .45-caliber handguns. Will takes the same Mountain Gun but prefers his in .44 Magnum.

It's interesting to see the popularity of the Smith & Wesson Mountain Gun concept. Three readers specified the Mountain Gun as their choice in .357, .41, and .44 Magnums.

One of the most interesting responses I got was from Steve McIntyre. Steve prefers the .38-40 caliber and says he'd like to see a fixed-sight, N-Frame revolver from Smith & Wesson in that caliber. Steve makes use of the large variety of .40 S&W and 10mm bullets to handload his ammunition. Since these bullets are intended for use in auto pistols they have no crimping grooves, but Steve takes care of that with a cannelure tool from CH.

And, finally, I heard from my old friend Charlie Pirtle from out in New Mexico. Charlie is a retired Border Patrolman and was a good friend of Skeeter Skelton's. Charlie is a pretty darn good hand with just about any handgun he might care to pick up. His preference, however, is for a First Generation Colt Single Action in

.38-40. Charlie's favored Colt has a 43/4-inch barrel, nickel finish, ivory grips, and a slicked-up action. Watching Charlie run a single-action sixgun through its paces would help folks realize that the single action is far from being an antique and thing from the past.

Several readers mentioned that some form of 1911 was among the guns on their short list, but I'm not surprised to see that most of the guns chosen were some sort of revolver. In this world of polymer frames and high-capacity magazines, the old revolver is still holding its own very well, including the single action. It's really not about how many bullets you can put into the air; it's about how many hits you can make. The modern revolver is a tough, reliable, and accurate companion for the handgunner.

And, of course, the whole one-gun debate is not about trying to convert someone to your way of thinking. It's really all about refining your own thinking and selecting a gun that actually fits your particular needs. Do you live in a rural or urban setting? Do you compete in shooting competition or handgun hunting? What are your plans for your own personal-protection program? These are the sorts of questions that we have to ask ourselves when deciding on the gun that suits our needs.

Finally, we ought to buy the very best firearm that we can possibly afford. A good gun, properly maintained, will outlive several generations of shooters. Through the years it becomes a familiar, comforting part of our lives.

It has been interesting to see the response to my one-gun column. But the important thing is that all of the guns mentioned are good guns. There's not a clunker in the bunch. And the fact is, I could make do with each and every one of them. I expect that you could, too, although I'm at a bit of a loss to figure out how to properly conceal that Model 94.

But I still shudder at the thought of actually being limited to one gun. We probably ought to take the time to be thankful that we live in a country in which that is not a reality. Maybe we also ought to be very careful who we cast our votes for so that some professional politician down the line doesn't force us to make that choice for real.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Hornady 6MM Creedmoor

Hornady 6MM Creedmoor

Tom Beckstrand and Neal Emery of Hornady highlight the 6MM Creedmoor ammo.

The Future Of Special Operations Small Arms

The Future Of Special Operations Small Arms

We're taking a look at what the Army's Elite Units are using for service rifles and what the future of SOCOM sniping looks like.

All About .300 Blackout

All About .300 Blackout

The .300 Blackout is here to stay, and we take some time to look at new technology surrounding this cartridge. Next, we pit subsonic rivals against each other before stretching the legs of this CQB round out to 600 yards from a short 9-inch barrel.

Black Hills Evolution of Rifle Cartridge: .308 Win. 175 Gr. Match

Black Hills Evolution of Rifle Cartridge: .308 Win. 175 Gr. Match

David Fortier talks with Jeff Hoffman of Black Hills Ammunition about the evolution of the .308 Win. 175 Gr. Match bullet.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

The joys of handloading are many, and one of them is sharing the experience with a novice.Share the Handloading Experience Reloading

Share the Handloading Experience

Lane Pearce - May 19, 2019

The joys of handloading are many, and one of them is sharing the experience with a novice.

The Winchester Model 52 is a fine, handbuilt smallbore match rifle that was once known as the king of the .22s among competition shooters.Winchester Model 52 Review Rifles

Winchester Model 52 Review

Joseph von Benedikt - July 20, 2020

The Winchester Model 52 is a fine, handbuilt smallbore match rifle that was once known as the...

A half-century in the making, the new DGX Bonded is Hornady's best-ever dangerous-game bullet.Danger Tamed: Hornady DGX Bonded Hunting Ammo Ammo

Danger Tamed: Hornady DGX Bonded Hunting Ammo

Joseph von Benedikt - May 23, 2019

A half-century in the making, the new DGX Bonded is Hornady's best-ever dangerous-game bullet.

The Husqvarna AB. Mauser Series 1100 Deluxe features a European walnut stock, a non-military action, and a two-position  wing-type safety.Husqvarna AB. Mauser Series 1100 Deluxe Rifle Review Rifles

Husqvarna AB. Mauser Series 1100 Deluxe Rifle Review

Joseph von Benedikt - August 19, 2020

The Husqvarna AB. Mauser Series 1100 Deluxe features a European walnut stock, a non-military...

See More Trending Articles

More Ammo

The new Winchester Active Duty 9mm ammo is loaded to the same military ballistics specifications as for the MHS program and has a rated muzzle velocity of 1,320 fps and a muzzle energy of 445 ft-lbs.Winchester Active Duty 9mm Ammo Review Ammo

Winchester Active Duty 9mm Ammo Review

Jake Edmondson - July 17, 2020

The new Winchester Active Duty 9mm ammo is loaded to the same military ballistics...

Berry's product line is extensive; in addition to making over 60 types of bullets, the firm also makes and sources many items for the reloader.Berry's Bullets: Reloading Equipment, Shooting Accessories & Bullet Accuracy Tests Ammo

Berry's Bullets: Reloading Equipment, Shooting Accessories & Bullet Accuracy Tests

Steve Gash - September 16, 2020

Berry's product line is extensive; in addition to making over 60 types of bullets, the firm...

The new aluminum-tipped ultra-low-drag Hornady A-Tip match bullet provides unprecedented performance.Hornady A-Tip Bullet Review Ammo

Hornady A-Tip Bullet Review

Jospeh von Benedikt - February 28, 2020

The new aluminum-tipped ultra-low-drag Hornady A-Tip match bullet provides unprecedented...

In single-shot firearms, .35-caliber rifle bullets are great performers in the .357 Maximum cartridge.Put the .357 Maximum Where It Works Ammo

Put the .357 Maximum Where It Works

Allan Jones - March 06, 2020

In single-shot firearms, .35-caliber rifle bullets are great performers in the .357 Maximum...

See More Ammo

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE Arrow

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Shooting Times subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now