Magnum Shotshells - Do We Really Need Them?

Magnum shotshells give shooters more of what they don't need, including more recoil, more muzzle blast, and long shot strings.

Magnum Shotshells - Do We Really Need Them?
Terry believes a balanced shotshell load, such as an ounce of #7½ shot in a 12-gauge wad cup, is the key to success for an above-average wingshooter. You don’t need to fall into shotgun magnumania.

Eons ago, when I was but a boy and dragons roamed the earth, some bright light in the shotshell industry decided that sales records could be broken if they stuffed twice as much shot into a shotshell, called it a “magnum,” and marketed the hell out of it.

Now, the very word “magnum” means different things to different shooters. To a rifleman, it means more powder and higher velocity in a particular bore size—the .300 H&H Magnum versus the .30-06, for example. To a shotgunner, it can mean many things, none of them good. Way back when, as I mentioned, it meant more shot in a payload—1½ ounces instead of 1⅛ ounces. Then they decided to throw in more velocity. Then they lengthened cases to get more of everything.

In fact, they got more of everything most people don’t want, such as recoil, muzzle blast, long shot strings, and blown patterns—all at vastly higher prices—and decidedly less of the two things that are essential in a shotgun: a nice, even pattern with no holes in it that goes where you are looking (at a bird, presumably) and not off into the heavens.

Years ago, I hunted with a guy who missed ducks regularly. Naturally, he believed it could not have been his shooting, so it had to be the ammunition, and every Saturday through the fall he showed up with heavier and heavier loads, convinced that the answer was more pellets in the air, moving ever faster. He spent a lot of money, but the bird count stayed the same. I missed a lot of birds, too, but my solution was to take up trap shooting and try to get better. And anyway, I was shooting a beautiful old Spanish 16-gauge double, and in a 16 gauge, then as now, you shoot what you can get. This was before steel shot.


In fact, the 16 gauge is a classic case in point. As a rule, the ammunition you can find is too hefty for everyday, 50-rounds-at-a-sitting skeet or sporting clays, and it’s not particularly good for game. It has never been lengthened to 3 inches (the Lord be praised!), but ammunition companies still try to turn it into a 12 gauge—and this to be used in a gun that might weigh, ideally, 6 pounds even. Thank you, no.


Generations of gun writers with inquiring minds—Sir Gerald Burrard in the 1920s, Gough Thomas in the ’60s, Bob Brister in the ’70s, and Michael McIntosh ever since—have experimented, tested, and more than adequately proven that you get the best pattern with a charge of shot that fits the bore and is propelled out the muzzle at around 1,100 to 1,200 (max!) feet per second. Some suggest a velocity as low as 1,050 fps, others allow that it can go as high as 1,250 fps, so 1,150 fps strikes me as probably ideal.

There are those who would argue that international trap loads are 24 grams (3/4 ounce) at much higher velocities. To which I can only reply that those loads are very specialized and used in guns with extremely tight chokes, which changes the equation substantially. For the above-average guy, with an above-average gun and above-average ability, the best chance of success lies with a nicely balanced load.

And what is that? In a 12 gauge, an ounce of #7½ shot in a standard shot cup is about as long as it is wide. At a velocity sufficient to initiate expansion, yet not so high as to blow the pattern, it can be expected to approximate the ideal “beach ball” pattern configuration as well as any. This is roughly the same as the old ideal of 1 ounce in the 16 gauge, but that was before shot cups changed the game.

As a writer, there is a certain gratification in joining a chorus that has been singing for more than a century. Alas, it’s a chorus that has been singing to an audience that seems determined to hear only the siren song of the magnum. It’s fortunate for the ammunition companies that so few shotgunners ever pattern their guns and, like my friend of days of yore, persist in the belief that they can cure bad shooting by putting ever-larger, ever-faster shot swarms into the air.


GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Tactical Solutions Introduces New X-Ring Takedown SBR Rifle

Tactical Solutions Introduces New X-Ring Takedown SBR Rifle

Keith Feeley of Tactical Solutions sat down with Michael Bane at SHOT Show 2018 to talk about the new X-Ring Takedown SBR .22LR rifle.

The Future Of Special Operations Small Arms

The Future Of Special Operations Small Arms

We're taking a look at what the Army's Elite Units are using for service rifles and what the future of SOCOM sniping looks like.

All About .300 Blackout

All About .300 Blackout

The .300 Blackout is here to stay, and we take some time to look at new technology surrounding this cartridge. Next, we pit subsonic rivals against each other before stretching the legs of this CQB round out to 600 yards from a short 9-inch barrel.

Pinging Steel At Over A Mile Away

Pinging Steel At Over A Mile Away

Big bore semiauto or a lever gun? We look at the futuristic .450 Bushmaster and how it compares to the tried and true .45-70. ISS Prop House gives us the rundown on the guns used in Enemy at the Gate. We ping steel with a .300 WinMag at over a mile.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

Harvey A. Donaldson may be best known for his .219 Donaldson Wasp wildcat cartridge, but during his lifetime he was popularly called the “pioneer benchrester.”  Gunsmithing

Harvey Donaldson: Pioneer Benchrester

Joel J. Hutchcroft - May 07, 2019

Harvey A. Donaldson may be best known for his .219 Donaldson Wasp wildcat cartridge, but...

Is the SIG P320 9mm modular pistol the best polymer-frame high-capacity sidearm ever designed? Let's find out. Handguns

SIG P320 9mm Review

Joseph Von Benedikt - September 13, 2018

Is the SIG P320 9mm modular pistol the best polymer-frame high-capacity sidearm ever designed?...

Shooting Times editor Joel Hutchcroft provides a comprehensive list of ideal Father's Day gifts. Accessories

Shooting Times Father's Day 2019 Gift Guide

Joel J. Hutchcroft - May 07, 2019

Shooting Times editor Joel Hutchcroft provides a comprehensive list of ideal Father's Day...

The new Bushnell FORGE riflescope is “the only choice for long-range hunting enthusiasts.” Optics

Review: Bushnell FORGE 4.5-27X 50mm

Sam Wolfenberger - May 01, 2019

The new Bushnell FORGE riflescope is “the only choice for long-range hunting enthusiasts.”

See More Trending Articles

More Ammo

In single-shot firearms, .35-caliber rifle bullets are great performers in the .357 Maximum cartridge. Ammo

Put the .357 Maximum Where It Works

Allan Jones - March 06, 2020

In single-shot firearms, .35-caliber rifle bullets are great performers in the .357 Maximum...

With a new location and the new 6.5 Rebated Precision Magnum (RPM) round, Weatherby breaks new ground in cartridge and rifle development. Ammo

Weatherby 6.5 RPM Cartridge Review

Joseph von Benedikt - March 25, 2020

With a new location and the new 6.5 Rebated Precision Magnum (RPM) round, Weatherby breaks new...

Starting in the late 1950s, the .338-bore size gained considerable traction — thanks to the .338 Winchester Magnum. Why? Because hunters are often after game bigger and tougher than whitetails. Here's a list of the .338-caliber greats in chronological order in which they were introduced. Ammo

11 Great .338 Caliber Rifle Cartridges

Payton Miller

Starting in the late 1950s, the .338-bore size gained considerable traction — thanks to the...

Magnum shotshells give shooters more of what they don't need, including more recoil, more muzzle blast, and long shot strings. Ammo

Magnum Shotshells - Do We Really Need Them?

Terry Wieland

Magnum shotshells give shooters more of what they don't need, including more recoil, more...

See More Ammo

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get Digital Access.

All Shooting Times subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now